Can you safely fast for 2 days or more while drinking only water? What side effects should you expect? Doctors, including Dr. Evelyne Bourdua-Roy, answer this question.
Water fasting for 2-3 days or more
Prolonged water fasting usually lasts two or more days, during which only water is consumed. Unlike intermittent fasting, which does not require medical supervision, people who are going to fast for several days by swallowing only water are often recommended to undergo a medical check-up before starting, and to consult immediately in the event of adverse effects.
Californian doctors wanted to know the adverse effects of this fast, and of the resumption of food following the fast. They analyzed 768 visit files from people (652 patients) who participated in a medically supervised fast in a Californian clinic between 2006 and 2011.
The majority of fasts (446) lasted 2 to 7 days. In 238 cases, the fast lasted 8 to 14 days, and in 64 cases 14 to 21 days. There were 20 fasts lasting more than 22 days, including one lasting 41 days.
The reasons why we do a total fast: the benefits attributed to fasting
The reasons that led people to fast were, in descending order:
- disease prevention, fatigue
- cardiovascular disorders, mainly hypertension
- osteoarthritis, bone problems, muscle pain
- gastrointestinal disorders including colitis, gastritis, constipation
- hormonal and metabolic disorders: thyroiditis, diabetes, blood sugar and blood lipid disorders
- neurological problems (headaches, neuropathies, dizziness)
- genitourinary disorders
- psychiatric disorders (depression, anxiety, difficulty concentrating)
- lung disorders
- eye, hearing, nose and throat problems
Read also: 7 potential health benefits of fasting (subscribers)
Note that to these reasons listed in the study, we can add weight control, general well-being and prevention of aging, which are also commonly put forward by fasters.
Everything you need to know about the side effects of water fasting
How are side effects classified?
Before discussing the adverse effects associated with prolonged water fasting, you should know that they are classified internationally according to their severity:
| Severity | Criteria |
| Grade 1 (light) | Does not affect the patient’s usual daily activity. Signs or symptoms most often requiring no treatment. |
| Grade 2 (moderate) | Disrupts the patient’s usual daily activity. Most often requires outpatient medical treatment without interruption of treatment. |
| Grade 3 (severe) | Prevents the patient’s usual daily activity. Requires treatment with hospitalization and/or interruption of treatment greater than or equal to 4 days. |
| Grade 4 (very severe) | Life-threatening. Impose resuscitation measures. |
| Grade 5 (death) | Fatal complication. |
Among the adverse reactions noted in the 768 medical records, 555 were grade 1 to 2, 212 were grade 3 and only one was grade 4. There were no grade 5 adverse reactions. The majority (75%) were mild.
The Most Common Side Effects of Fasting
In this study, complaints were associated with the duration of fasting.
The most frequent complaints were fatigue (48.2% of complaints), nausea (32.2%), insomnia (33.5%), headaches (30.1%), dyspepsia (25.9%), back pain (25.7%). These complaints were mainly grade 1 and are often noted during prolonged fasting.
Presyncope was the subject of 28.3% of visits; This is a known adverse effect of fasting, most often grade 2.
For the other adverse effects identified, it is difficult to know whether these complaints are linked to the fast itself or to the state of health of the patients before the fast. Indeed, they overlap with the very reasons that led these people to fast.
In practice
Is therapeutic fasting dangerous? The opinion of scientists
The authors of this study conclude that the majority of adverse effects seen during prolonged water fasting are mild to moderate and are well-known reactions to this type of fasting. They therefore consider that in the majority of cases, fasting is not dangerous if it is limited to a few days. Despite everything, they recommend medical monitoring of patientss. And the latter should be all the more systematic if the person is elderly, has a medical history and/or takes medication.
However, you should know that prolonged fasting, even in a perfectly healthy person, can lead to a loss of muscle mass and deficits in several nutrients. For example, an otherwise healthy, overweight man drank only water for 44 days. Results: He lost about 25% of his body mass, a quarter to a third of which was body fat, and the rest was mostly muscle. In this study, this patient was found to be deficient in vitamin B1 (thiamine), B2 (riboflavin), and K. Vitamin B1 deficiency can lead to a form of encephalopathy. These risks should lead to the question of the benefit of prolonged fasting (benefit/risk balance).
How to prepare for fasting to avoid adverse effects and maintain it?
Preparing for fasting can be helpful against adverse effects. Many practitioners gradually reduce their coffee or tea consumption a week before, starting to skip meals or eat lighter meals in the days before. Some authors recommend gradually eliminating the different families of foods, starting with meat, then dairy products, then cereals and fats and finally fruits and vegetables on the day the fast begins.
Mental preparation is also important. If people around you are eating, it is best to plan to go out during meal preparation and/or eating to avoid being tempted. specialists also advise avoiding temptations and above all listening to yourself too much (watching for hunger, the slightest undesirable sign, etc.).
What to drink during a fast? What place for coffee?
You can drink any unsweetened beverage during a fast. If you opt for a broth, it is better to make sure that it is not made with vegetables that are too high in carbohydrates (like potatoes).
The first drink is water and it is the only one authorized for water fasting. It can be mineralized water to compensate for mineral losses like Rozana or Vichy St Yorre.
For other fasts, unsweetened coffee and tea are also possible even if some purists advise against them. You can add a tablespoon of vegetable oil (olive, rapeseed, coconut) or medium-chain triglycerides. Herbal teas, unsweetened and without added fruit, can be drinks of choice.
Counteracting adverse effects during fasting
What to do in case of diarrhea during fasting?
Diarrhea, explains Dr. Evelyne Bourdua-Roy, who founded the Reversa clinic in Quebec and co-wrote “How to Fast,” is frequently reported, particularly when people are not used to this practice. Its appearance, she says, does not signify ongoing detoxification but the body’s evacuation of excess water: this comes from the fact that the body uses stored glycogen as an energy source and that the latter is attached to water molecules, which are released when it is used. Furthermore, drinking coffee or tea can have a diuretic effect. “If nausea and/or vomiting accompany diarrhea,” says Dr. Bourdua-Roy, it is better to stop the fast and consult immediately.
How to react to hunger?
“It’s normalsays Dr Bourdua-Roy, especially during the first 24 hours of fasting to feel hungry. It often manifests itself by gurgling sounds which appear in more or less intense waves, before disappearing.“Knowing that the wave of hunger will pass, advises the doctor, we can just recognize its presence and let it go away by itself; we can also take the opportunity to drink sparkling water, or even short-circuit it by doing a little physical exercise.”Sleeping or meditating can be good strategies to stop thinking about hunger“.
Tips against bad breath
According to Dr Bourdua-Roy, bad breath can be linked to the fact that the stomach is empty; it can also occur after 24 hours of fasting when ketone bodies begin to be produced to serve as fuel for cells. Besides brushing your teeth, she advises, you can combat bad breath with mouthwashes, using peppermint essential oil or chewing fresh mint leaves. Another tip: drink water with a little cider vinegar or gargle with this mixture.
Good reflexes in case of headaches
“Headache that occurs during a fastexplains Dr Bourdua-Roy, generally comes either from slight dehydration with lack of salt, or from caffeine withdrawal if the latter has not been stopped gradually before the fast. But it can also be caused by a lack of sleep or stress hormones in people who are not or no longer used to fasting..”
In case of a headache, specialists advise drinking a large glass of water rich in magnesium, adding a little salt (even if some water fasting purists advise against it). If the headache persists 20 minutes after ingestion of this drink, you must ask yourself the question of a lack of sleep or caffeine.
To be tested in case of fatigue
Against sudden shocks, the first remedy, says Dr. Bourdua-Roy, is the same as that against headaches: drink a large glass of water containing 1/4 to 1/2 teaspoon. salt. Here too, fatigue can be due to lack of sleep or stress.
How to break a water fast?
It is best to break the fast gently and the longer it has been, the more important this advice is.
Overeating after a fast can cause an uncomfortable stomach upset. It is therefore best to break the fast with a snack or a light meal. In all cases, choose small portions and chew well. Don’t forget to drink either.
Here are some snacks to gently break a fast:
- A handful of walnuts, almonds, hazelnuts or a spoonful of almond or peanut puree
- A small bowl of raw vegetables seasoned with a few drops of olive oil and vinegar
- A bowl of vegetable broth with vegetables
- A little meat or ham
You can then have a light meal 1 to 2 hours later. Some authors advise avoiding eggs and dairy products during the first meals. It’s up to everyone to test what suits them, knowing that the longer the fast, the more precautions are necessary.
