Diabetes is no longer truly an incurable disease. Evidence has been provided that a low-calorie or low-carbohydrate diet can reverse the disease in some patients. A recent study shows that this is also true when diet is combined with exercise.
Type 2 diabetes is generally considered an irreversible and incurable pathology. Characterized by a fasting blood sugar level greater than 1.26 g/L (or 7 mmol/L), it often leads to complications which can be serious.
According to the International Diabetes Federation, one in nine people worldwide lives with diabetes. In France, more than 4.4 million people will have diabetes in 2024 and the disease affects men more frequently than women, except in overseas territories. According to Public Health France, 5.3% of the population was treated with antidiabetic drugs in 2020, or 3.5 million people. In 2020, one in five men aged 70 to 85 and one in seven women aged 75 to 85 were treated for diabetes. According to the ESTEBAN 2014-2016 survey, the prevalence of undiagnosed diabetes among 18-74 year olds was estimated at 1.7%, and that of prediabetes at 9.9%.
Diabetes is not incurable
Type 2 diabetes was once thought to be irreversible and progressive, but a series of clinical studies conducted over the past 12 years have clarified the mechanisms that cause the disease. Researchers from Newcastle University, led by Professor Roy Taylor, showed in 2011 that diabetes can be reversed in some patients thanks to a 2-month low-calorie diet. It remained to be seen whether diabetes could return. They subsequently showed that the benefits obtained by these patients persisted at least 6 months later. This study shows that for a so-called “incurable” disease, people with type 2 diabetes can “reverse” their diabetes.
The experiment was carried out on 30 diabetic men and women volunteers (type 2 diabetics), constructed in 2 phases:
- phase 1 : individuals had to interrupt all their drug treatments and insulin injections while following a very strict diet of 600/700 kcal/day for two months (weight loss phase);
- phase 2 : for the following 6 months, they had to follow an isocaloric diet combined with a personalized weight maintenance program (stabilization phase).
The participants in the study lost an average of 14 kilos after the 2 months of strict diet, and had not regained any after the stabilization phase. 12 of the 30 study participants had normal blood sugar levels at the end of the weight loss phase. Six months later, all patients who had reversed their diabetes (40% of the initial group) saw the benefits maintained, with one additional patient also managing to reverse their diabetes.
These results were confirmed in 2019.
“We now know that the processes that cause type 2 diabetessays Professor Roy Taylor, can be reversed by restricting calories, in order to achieve a weight loss of approximately 15 kg. About half of people who were diagnosed with diabetes less than 10 years ago manage to follow the dietary energy restriction program can stop all diabetes medications and return the blood sugar level of a healthy person. Remission is achieved when glycated hemoglobin concentrations, or A1c, of 48 mmol/mol are recorded after weight loss and for at least six months without taking antidiabetic medication.”
A low-calorie diet combined with exercise
Type 2 diabetes appears earlier and earlier. Diagnosed before the age of 45, it progresses more quickly, its complications occur earlier and it reduces life expectancy more than when it occurs later. Researchers from the universities of Leicester (United Kingdom) and McGill (Canada) recruited 96 obese adults aged 18 to 45, who had type 2 diabetes for less than 6 years and were not treated with insulin. Half followed 12 weeks of a very low-calorie diet (800 to 900 kcal per day, first in the form of meal replacements, then with one real meal per day), with 2 supervised exercise sessions per week (endurance and muscle strengthening). Diabetes medications were stopped. This was followed by 12 weeks of weight stabilization, without stopping physical activity. The other half received usual care.
At 6 months, the diet + exercise group had lost 7.5 kg more than the control group, and 54% of participants were in remission, compared to 4% of controls. Side effects (constipation, headaches, fatigue) were common but temporary.
Adding exercise to the diet mainly served to preserve muscle. “The participants lost a lot of weight while retaining their muscle mass,” explains Professor Thomas Yates (University of Leicester), on the Healio website. According to him, the reduction in visceral fat and liver fat is “comparable to that obtained with anti-obesity drugs”. For Professor Kaberi Dasgupta (McGill University), exercise helps improve your fitness, muscle size and strength, but “exercise alone generally does not help you lose weight”. The program was demanding, but almost all the participants played the game: “Even though it was a lot to ask, people appreciated it,” she adds.
This study remains short (6 months) and it did not include a “diet only” group: we cannot therefore know what exercise contributes in addition to diet to achieve remission. It nevertheless confirms that early type 2 diabetes can also be reversed, provided that action is taken quickly and with medical support.
Low-carb diets
Low-carbohydrate diets such as Atkins (low carb) or ketogenic diets are an alternative to low-calorie diets. Several studies show that patients who follow such diets lose weight, have better blood sugar control and can reduce medication doses.
“We now have many dietary therapies, including low-carb and ketogenic diets, to effectively manage type 2 diabetes.“, says Dr. Bourdua-Roy, who wrote The Big Book of Metabolic Health. The ketogenic or keto diet is a diet very low in carbohydrates (less than 50 g/day) and high in fats (more than 75% of total energy). It leads to nutritional ketosis, that is to say the appearance of ketone bodies derived from fats, which mainly serve as fuel for cells, says Dr. Bourdua-Roy. This ketosis reduces hunger.
Read the interview with Dr Bourdua-Roy
The embarrassment of choosing nutritional treatment
Diabetes under 10 years old can now be reversed through dietary and lifestyle changes. This may be a low-calorie diet such as Newcastle University, or a low-carbohydrate diet such as Atkins or as recommended by Dr Bourdua-Roy. Dietary advice can facilitate better long-term adherence, for example by favoring Mediterranean or vegetarian dishes. Researchers also agree that we should avoid ultra-processed foods and eat more fresh, whole foods.
